|
Loading... The Dogs of Bedlam Farm: An Adventure with Sixteen Sheep, Three Dogs, Two…por Jon KatzSéries: Bedlam Farm (2)
Recomendações do LibraryThingRecomendações de membrosNenhuma. A carregar...
não
provavelmente não
provavelmente sim
sim
adorará Adira ao LibraryThing para descobrir se gostará deste livro. I had just finished the previous book of his about Devon/Orson and his two labs. I really enjoyed it and was looking forward to the follow up. Unfortunately I didn't enjoy this one at all. First of all, the first 50 pages or so made little to no mention of the dogs and was primarily about his move to the farm and the new town he's living in. I was giving the book about 50 pages or so and I was going to not finish it if he never came back to the animals. Just about that time he focused back on the dogs. He talks quite a bit about how much his dogs mean to him, how he loves the sheep he brought to the farm (even at one point about how he had a vet perform surgery on an injured sheep when others in the community told him he should have just put it down) and how he's so attached to Carol the donkey. Yet then I came to the chapter about a cat that was on the property and the bottom line is he shot the cat with a rifle because it had tangled with the dogs one time too many. At that point I put the book down immediately, because as a cat lover I don't think that was at all necessary. I'm sure there are people who could justify his actions but I think there other options that could have been looked at without having to resort to killing that poor animal. ( )The Dogs of Bedlam Farm, by Jon Katz, is a likable read about the author's first year of being a hobby farmer raising a few sheep. Katz tries to learn more about himself by looking at how he works with his dogs. With references to St. Augustine coupled to descriptions of first-time farmer antics, it seemed to me Katz was trying to go in too many directions at once. However, as a dog owner and closet wanna-be farmer, I also enjoyed Katz's descriptions of trying to fit into his rural community, his first forays into herding, and his obvious deep love of his dogs. Katz’s story is interesting, but not as good as some of the “dog stories” I have read. For example: “At some point I’d begun to enter the murky area where the boundary between the human’s issues and dog’s trouble blurs” (120). Maybe it’s just me, but I hate the kind of repetition in this sentence. If an area is already “murky,” how could you see something “blurry”? The story is amusing (they are making a movie of his life), but it simply did not affect me as much as the recent Marley & Me by John Grogan. Katz focuses on the one-way relationship between him and his dogs, and does not look too deeply into the actions of the dogs and the motivation of their relationships with owners and other animals. Worth a read. --Chiron, 7/8/07, Three stars An enjoyable story, if a little far fetched. It falls into that category of books about people with means (and all the trappings that come with them) trying to live a "simpler" life. It's a category most folks could only dream about, still Katz is a good storyteller and offers a good tale. And thanks to a lot of help from a lot of friends, he survives his "simple" adventure. Being a sheep farmer and the 'mother' of two border collies, I'm afraid I'm going to be too critical of this book. The author "gives up everything" to go be a sheep 'farmer'. Well, sixteen sheep do NOT make you a true sheep farmer. And, I could only wish that I had a vet who would just stop by to check in on me and neighbors who drop everything to come do my chores for me. It just wasn't really a 'true' sheep farming experience. At least, not to someone who has a flock of 200 sheep and is having more than that many lambs during a lambing season. It was a 'fun' read but not a realistic read for anyone who farms for a living. sem resenhas | adicionar uma resenha
Referências a esta obra em recursos externos.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Descrição do livro |
|
(retirado da Amazon Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:57:57 -0400)
A primeira ronda de testes foi já encerrada. Visite o grupo Open Shelves Classification para mais informação.
Ligações Rápidas |