Christopher Alexander of A Pattern Language fame has written a philosophical work proclaiming a universal visual aesthetics (in the unacknowledged footsteps of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe). Although he repeatedly claims to follow a scientific approach, his holistic style is based on visual gut "proof" of preferring one of two pictures. In contrast to the explanations and links to scientific experiments in A Pattern Language, he relies on leap of faith argumentation.

Instead of the Nature of Order the book's content is better described as the order of nature. Alexander identifies fifteen fundamental properties which create "life" (his term for Gemütlichkeit or Danish Hygge, attractive and cozy) and "wholesomeness" (his term for agreeable complexity). These fifteen pattern are a workable set out of the treasure chest of A Pattern Language and may help designers improve their creations (If only Alexander's own work were a better showcase for it.).

Alexander's preference for the organic, the hand-made, the imperfect, the old is charming but futile in today's mass produced and standardized world. He should have included good modern designs and buildings of which there are plenty. It would only strengthen his argumentation - but not his way of arguing. The book is full of examples of Alexander having (bullying?) people accept his interpretation as the only valid one. At times, it is bizarre and almost nutty: Is your inner self more like a salt shaker or a ketchup bottle? An ax or a screwdriver? A dime or a nickel? The gospel's of Alexander only valid answer is the first choice. Repent, reader and see the light!

If you are reading just one book by Alexander, let it be the superior A Pattern Language, followed by A Timeless Way of Building. ( )

http://www.archidose.org/books/alexan... ( )