Picture of author.
20+ Works 694 Membros 2 Críticas

About the Author

Inclui os nomes: Mary Jo Buhle, Mari Jo Buhle

Obras por Mari Jo Buhle

Encyclopedia of the American Left (1990) — Editor; Contribuidor, algumas edições105 exemplares
The American Radical (1994) 38 exemplares
A Concise Women's History (2014) 4 exemplares

Associated Works

Etiquetado

Conhecimento Comum

Membros

Críticas

In Feminism and Its Discontents: A Century of Struggle with Psychoanalysis, Mari Jo Buhle writes, “Psychoanalysis and feminism both concern the meaning of individuality in a secular society and, as philosophical systems, gained coherence only as this century began. Psychoanalysis took shape as a clinical or therapeutic method, feminism as a political strategy. The two systems occupied a common domain as theories of human liberation, even at subsequent moments of conflict of competition” (pg. 3). She argues that the two systems developed in conversation with each other and that, where psychoanalysis inspired feminists to refine their analytical categories, feminism forced psychoanalysts to address Freud’s blindspots. Buhle continues, “Psychoanalysis in the United States quickly became, as Freud predicted, the property of freewheeling intellectuals and popularists as well as of physicians” (pg. 6). Further, “Some of the responsibility for this process lay with psychoanalysts themselves and other scholars trained in the discipline. Karl Menninger wrote a column for the Ladies’ Home Journal in the early 1930s; Margaret Mead picked up the thread decades later in her regular contributions to Redbook. After World War II the most prominent psychoanalysts enjoyed long runs on the nonfiction bestseller list and met with even greater success when their books were reprinted as mass-market paperbacks” (pg. 7). Finally, Buhle provides “a historical context for the shift from feminist ‘thought’ to ‘theory,’ precisely at the nexus between feminism and psychoanalysis” (pg. 21).

Discussing the late 1940s and the portrayal of psychoanalysis in popular culture, Buhle writes, “Psychoanalysts themselves contributed to the processes of popularization. Several prominent analysts, such as New York’s A.A. Brill and Gregory Zilboorg, literally served the entertainment industry by building their clientele from its stars” (pg. 168). Further, “Psychoanalysis walked hand in hand with mass culture through its Golden Age. Its celebrity among intellectuals not only accompanied but nourished the rapid expansion of commercialized mass media” (pg. 169). Examining the status of psychoanalysis in the immediate postwar years, Buhle writes, “Much of the glory of psychoanalysis arose from its enhanced professional standing” (pg. 170). She links this with postwar antifeminism, writing, “At a time when white middle-class wives and mothers constituted the fastest-growing sector of the labor market, thereby speeding the long trend toward the ‘two-income family,’ psychoanalysts were advising women to return home and to occupy their important but subordinate position in the patriarchal family. Rather than struggle for equality in the marketplace, women should seek their emotional salvation by following out their reproductive destinies” (pg. 173). Psychoanalysts further argued that women in the workplace would affect the healthy sexual development of children (pg. 191).
… (mais)
½
 
Assinalado
DarthDeverell | Mar 23, 2020 |
Journal entry from October 18, 1993

Mari Jo Buhle has claimed that she was inspired to study the relationship between women and American socialism by "the uneasy relationship of the New Left and the Women's Movement circa 1970" which she observed as a graduate student at the University of Wisconsin, Madison. Since that time she has sought to combine "Questions of 'class' and 'gender' in movements for, and in theories of, social change." Women and American .Socialism, 1870-1920 is concerned with exactly this relationship between gender and class as categories of analysis. Building on the work of Herbert Gutman and E. P. Thompson, Buhle examines women's struggles as an integral part of American socialism. As she explains in her introduction, she seeks to render the narrative of proletairianization more complete by studying the "other side of the battle lines," that is by telling the women's story.

(For biographical info on Mari Jo Buhle see Contemporary Authors 108: 80-18. Ann J. Lane's brief review of Women and American Socialism in Journal of American History 69 (September 1982): 471-2 introduces the book by saying that this book is an example of how "the new scholarship of the past decade on women has, by enriching our understanding of the place of women, 8deepened our understanding of the historical process in general." )

As a way of addressing the tensions between gender and class in the workers' movement in America, Buhle talks about the different conceptions which native-born and German-American women had of the role of women in the socialist movement. German-American socialist women placed the concerns of their class ahead of the demands of their gender. They were workers first, women second. Native-born American socialist women considered the betterment of women's lot to be inextricably linked to the triumph of socialism, for them class and gender formed an indissoluble unity. The tension between these visions was present at the creation of the American socialist movement .in post-Civil War America. It is Buhle's contention that American socialism has never reconciled these two visions of socialism. It may even be that the New Left-Women's Movement tensions "circa 1970" echo these themes as well.

In Chapter 1, "German-American Socialists and the Women Question," Buhle presents the German-American Hausfrau as the inheritor of a peculiar German legacy of romanticism, which meant that even Socialists "apotheosized the worker and his family, the microcosm of a universal people's culture about to realize age-old aspirations in the coming events" (p. 9). This romanticisized domesticity included a German version of the "cult of true womanhood" which relegated women to suitably domestic endeavors even within Socialism. German-American .Socialist women remained politically unsophisticated and contented themselves for the most part with helping and supporting their male counterparts (p. 17). Early Frauenvereine of the 1870s "offered busy women party loyalists extra responsibility without the compensation of real prestige or power in the movement" (p. 18). The later Frauenbunde of the 1880s were "less an extension of their familial roles and more an expression of women's own interests" such that this movement could be called the first German-American women's Socialist political organization (p. 33). Both were limited by their all pervasive German Romanticism.

(Since recent scholarship on 19th century German history has called into question this very notion of German peculiarity, there may be a way out for Buhle's women. Their "Europeanness" may be more important than their "Germanness." See the seminal work by David Blackbourn and Geoff Eley The Peculiarities of German History: Bourgeois Society and Politics in Nineteenth-Century Germany, Oxford: Oxford UP, 1991. There is also considerable evidence that the type of German radicalism which Buhle assumes is hegemonic in Germany during the 19th century, that is a highly organized and structured movement, is not the only type of radicalism to emerge in Germany as a response to the consolidation of corporate capitalism. See in this connection Erhard Lucas' Zwei Formen von Radicalismus in der deutschen Arbeiterbewegung (Two Forms of Radicalism in the German Workers' Movement), Verlag Roter Stern, 1976. Lucas contends that in addition to the tradition which Buhle refers to of a German SPD-oriented union-centered radicalism there is also a more "spontaneous" extra-party radicalism which developed particularly in such towns as Hamborn, in which the Thyssen mining concern created a great industrial center out of whole cloth in the late 19th century. Hamborn radicalism included a much greater women's component than did the type to which Buhle refers and Lucas associates with Remscheid. If Lucas is right, then perhaps Buhle has flattened her picture 8of German roots. See Davis "German History From Unification to Unification" Binder I, Week 4 for summary of Lucas' book.)

Within the contexts of this Frauenverband movement, Buhle uses Johanna Greie as an example of the possibility for a true women's movement which went beyond domesticity and the subordinate role of women. Capitalizing on August Bebel's legitimization of female wage labor, Greie cast women workers as worthy of the vote (they too had property in their own labor, p. 37). Riding high on the upsurge of labor success in the strike wave of the mid-1880s, Greie's brand of Frauenbund Socialism ended up failing in the 1880s along with the Knights of Labor. The reasons for this promising movement's demise remain troublingly unclear in Buhle's account.

In Chapter 2, "Woman's Movement and Socialism," an entirely .different tradition of women and American Socialism emerges. Native-born American women were heiresses of the tradition of radicalism embodied by temperance crusades and abolitionism in antebellum America. For example here German-American women accepted alcohol consumption as part of the pattern of life brought over from the old country, native-born women Socialists turned the temperance crusade into a battle against the corruption of a male-dominated polity (p. 53). Out of this native radical tradition (where do the Grimke sisters fit?), grew the commitment to "sisterly solidarity" which marked this vision of Socialism (p. 56). Native-born women organized across class lines and entered more easily into civil society, using .the metaphor of domesticity to, in the words of Frances Willard of the WCTU, "make the whole world HOMELIKE" (p. 65).

The native-born women who embraced socialism employed "womanly virtue against marketplace capitalism, cooperation overcoming competition, social reconstruction rather than class warfare" (p. 70) Frances Willard was drawn to Edward Bellamy's collectivist Nationalism, but had difficulty winning over other women to the cause (pp. 80-81). Activities such as those of the Women's Christian Temperance Movement (WCTU) had prepared native-born women for participation in the Grange and ultimately in Populism. Populist women chose Ignatius Donnelly (sp?) as their ideological standard bearer (p. 84), but did not realize their goals with the Alliance Party. Within the Socialist Labor Party, too, the native-born women Socialists were disappointed. There the German-American faction triumphed. Native-born radicalism was ill-suited to the class warfare approach of German-American Socialists, and the German-Americans denounced them as bourgeois (p.92).

The end of Populism (we shall not say defeat, since Hofstadter has shown that they were ultimately one of the most successful third party movements in American history) and the degeneration of the SLP into "a mere sect" in the early 20th century, did not mean the end of women's activism. The struggles of the 1880s and 90s had trained a new generation of leaders.
… (mais)
 
Assinalado
mdobe | Jul 24, 2011 |

Listas

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Paul Buhle Editor
Teresa Murphy Contributor
Ring Jr. Lardner Contributor
Eric Foner Foreword
Mark D. Naison Contributor
Richard Judd Contributor
Linn Shapiro Contributor
Michael Karni Contributor
Paul Jr. Robeson Contributor
Joanne Melish Contributor
Paul C. Mishler Contributor
John Sillito Contributor
Norman Markowitz Contributor
Kenneth Teitelbaum Contributor
Kent Worcester Contributor
Ellen Wiley Todd Contributor
David Hacker Contributor
Charles H. Martin Contributor
Leslie F. Orear Contributor
Norma Jenckes Contributor
Mike Konopacki Contributor
Samuel R. Friedman Contributor
Ernie Brill Contributor
Maxine Phillips Contributor
Alan Wald Contributor
Ralph Stone Contributor
Maurice Jackson Contributor
Jack Stuart Contributor
Peter Rachleff Contributor
Jill Raymond Contributor
Robert Shaffer Contributor
Howard Zinn Contributor
Richard Nickson Contributor
Kathleen Weiler Contributor
Margaret Strobel Contributor
Alan Wallach Contributor
Joseph R. Urgo Contributor
Alan Singer Contributor
George E. Pozzetta Contributor
Evan Stark Contributor
Morris U. Schappes Contributor
James Lerner Contributor
Steven Fraser Contributor
Taylor Stoehr Contributor
Cecile Whiting Contributor
Amy Swerdlow Contributor
Constance Webb Contributor
Renqiu Yu Contributor
Marc S. Miller Contributor
Sally M. Miller Contributor
Malcolm Sylvers Contributor
Annette Rubinstein Contributor
Douglas Monroy Contributor
Ralph E. Shaffer Contributor
Michael Honey Contributor
David Roediger Contributor
Mark Tushnet Contributor
Mark Maier Contributor
William A. Reuben Contributor
Allen Ruff Contributor
Mel Rosenthal Contributor
Steven Rosswurm Contributor
Albert Prago Contributor
Devra Weber Contributor
Paul Le Blanc Contributor
Nancy Krieger Contributor
Jim Jacobs Contributor
Daniel Georgianna Contributor
Nancy L. Roberts Contributor
Gene Degruson Contributor
Matjaz Klemencic Contributor
Margaret Sandburg Contributor
Waler J. Lear Contributor
George Pirinsky Contributor
David Paskin Contributor
Prairie Miller Contributor
Blaine McKinley Contributor
Al McAloon Contributor
Robert Macieski Contributor
Andy Lanset Contributor
Ruth F. Prago Contributor
Peter Kuznick Contributor
Robert Kornstad Contributor
Christine Hess Contributor
Olufson Hauge Contributor
Marv Gettleman Contributor
Tara Fitzpatrick Contributor
Don Fritz Contributor
Chuck Portz Contributor
Bill Falkowski Contributor
Gregory M. Stone Contributor
Maria Woroby Contributor
Nora R. Wainer Contributor
Jean Tussey Contributor
Michael Topp Contributor
Richard Taskin Contributor
Mary Lou Suhor Contributor
Nancy B. Sinkoff Contributor
Sid Resnick Contributor
Sam Sills Contributor
William Sennett Contributor
Joel Saxe Contributor
Sal Salerno Contributor
Alex Rosner Contributor
David Riehle Contributor
Thomas Fiehrer Contributor
Bret Enyon Contributor
Arieh Lebowitz Contributor
Doug Reynolds Contributor
Joseph Blum Contributor
Rob Rosenthal Contributor
Michael Staub Contributor
Richard W. Thomas Contributor
Peter Buckingham Contributor
Dianne Feeley Contributor
Christina L. Baker Contributor
Leonard Rifas Contributor
Joe Doyle Contributor
Ben Perry Contributor
Rose Lewis Contributor
John Cort Contributor
Daniel Soyer Contributor
Dorothy Swanson Contributor
Francis Shor Contributor
Frank Emspak Contributor
Ara Dostourian Contributor
Annette P. Bus Contributor
Velma Doby Contributor
Robert D'Attilo Contributor
Mary Cygan Contributor
Harold Christoffel Contributor
Jules Chametsky Contributor
Eric Breibart Contributor
John Jentz Contributor
Stephane Booth Contributor
Rudolf Baranik Contributor
Anna Maria Alonso Contributor
Ernest Allen, Jr. Contributor
Jerry Lembcke Contributor
S. Carl Hirsch Contributor
Ulrike Heider Contributor
Dana Frank Contributor
Robert W. Cherny Contributor
Robert Armstrong Contributor
Patrick Manning Contributor
Penelope Rosemont Graphics advisor
Paul Richards Contributor
George W. Carey Contributor
Rebecca Zurier Contributor
Alice Wexler Contributor
David Konstan Contributor
John A. Miller Contributor
Paul Garon Contributor
James Gilbert Contributor
Leon Fink Contributor
Van Gosse Contributor
Walter Schneir Contributor
Joel Kovel Contributor
Mark Kesselman Contributor
Barbara Bair Contributor
Robert Asher Contributor
Carolyn Ashbaugh Contributor
Muhammad Ahmad Contributor
Frank Adams Contributor
Nabeel Abraham Contributor
Martin Glaberman Contributor
Alexander Bloom Contributor
David Marc Contributor
David J. Goldberg Contributor
Gerald Horne Contributor
Hedda Garza Contributor
Philip G. Altbach Contributor
Phillip Berryman Contributor
Françoise Basch Contributor
Aaron Lansky Contributor
Russell Jacoby Contributor
Paul Smith Contributor
Ruth Rosen Contributor
Noel Ignatiev Contributor
Eric Homberger Contributor
Linda Gordon Contributor
Robin D. G. Kelley Contributing editor
Miriam Schneir Contributor
Robert Cohen Contributor
James Miller Contributor
Michael Lerner Contributor
Juan Williams Contributor
Kirkpatrick Sale Contributor
Sean Wilentz Contributor
Harvey Pekar Contributor
Nell Irvin Painter Contributor
George Lipsitz Contributor
Tom Bottomore Contributor
Kathryn Kish Sklar Contributor
John Graham Contributor
Franklin Rosemont Contributing editor
Robert Fisher Contributor
Ellen Carol DuBois Contributor
Herb Boyd Contributor
Maurice Isserman Contributor
Alice Echols Contributor
Douglas Kellner Contributor
Barbara Garson Contributor
Ellen Schrecker Contributor
Clayborne Carson Contributor
Michael Kazin Contributor
Roy Rosenzweig Contributor
Michael Denning Contributor
James R. Barrett Contributor
Roger Keeran Contributor
David Peck Contributor
Richard Levy Contributor
Saul Landau Contributor
Alfred Young Contributor
Priscilla Long Contributor
Fred Whitehead Contributing editor
Dirk Hoerder Contributor
Daniel Nugent Contributor
Rudolph J. Vecoli Contributor
Temma Kaplan Contributor
Nunzio Pernicone Contributor
Richard Quinney Contributor
Tim Wohlforth Contributor
Bruce Nelson Contributor
Irwin Klibaner Contributor
Arnold Rampersand Contributor
Joseph Jablonski Contributor
Steve Sherman Contributor
Arthur Zipser Contributor
Fay M. Blake Contributor
Gerald Markowitz Contributor
Robert Greene Contributor
David McReynolds Contributor
Mark Selden Contributor
Elliott Shore Contributor
Joyce L. Kornbluh Contributor
Scott Molloy Contributor
Bruno Ramirez Contributor
Carol Poore Contributing editor
Lise Vogel Contributor
Enzo Traverso Contributor
Yuji Ichioka Contributor
Herbert Shapiro Contributor
Dave Wagner Contributor
Paul N. Siegel Contributor
Edward D. Beechert Contributor
Larry Ceplair Contributor
David DeLeon Contributor
John De Graaf Contributor
Eric Leif Davin Contributor
Richard Criley Contributor
John P. Clark Contributor
Lawrence Bush Contributor
Lorraine Brown Contributor
Paul Breines Contributor
Jon Bloom Contributing editor
Martin Blatt Contributor
Steve Best Contributor
Bettina Berch Contributor
Peter Drucker Contributor
Harry Fleischman Contributor
Pat Hills Contributor
Jeffrey Haydu Contributor
Benjamin Harris Contributor
Marilyn Halter Contributor
Rick Halpern Contributor
Max Gordon Contributor
Steve Golin Contributor
David Goldway Contributor
Ann Fagan Ginger Contributor
Philip S. Foner Contributor
Toni Gilpin Contributor
Mark I. Gelfand Contributor
Dee Garrison Contributor
Virginia Gardner Contributor
Mario T. Garcia Contributor
Miriam Frank Contributor
James Wrenn Contributor

Estatísticas

Obras
20
Also by
1
Membros
694
Popularidade
#36,476
Avaliação
4.1
Críticas
2
ISBN
114

Tabelas & Gráficos