Chapman Cohen (1868–1954)
Autor(a) de Theism or Atheism: The Great Alternative
Obras por Chapman Cohen
Thomas Paine: Pioneer of Two Worlds 1 exemplar
Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live 1 exemplar
Did Jesus Christ exist? 1 exemplar
Essays in Freethinking - Volume One 1 exemplar
Freethought and the child 1 exemplar
What is Freethought? 1 exemplar
Deity and design 1 exemplar
Giving 'em hell 1 exemplar
Gods and their makers 1 exemplar
Must we have a religion? 1 exemplar
What is the use of prayer? 1 exemplar
The devil 1 exemplar
Essays in Freethinking 1 exemplar
Associated Works
Etiquetado
Conhecimento Comum
- Data de nascimento
- 1868-09-01
- Data de falecimento
- 1954-02-04
- Sexo
- male
Membros
Críticas
You May Also Like
Associated Authors
Estatísticas
- Obras
- 28
- Also by
- 1
- Membros
- 60
- Popularidade
- #277,520
- Avaliação
- 4.0
- Críticas
- 1
- ISBN
- 13
Cohen hits it hard right away Bam! and Bam! Bam! Remember, this was 1921! He says, "The purpose of the following pages is to make clear the nature of this alliance [theism and philosophy] and to expose the real character of what we are asked to worship." He rightly observes "There are, of course, many on whose ears any amount of reasoning will fall without effect." He also observes that "we have been where the Theist is, [but] he has not been where we are."
On defining "What is God?", he gets to a point saying, "It is a tacit admission that human welfare depends on our knowledge and manipulation of the forces by which we are surrounded." (Ever the "proper" grammar!) And he answers an implied question - Why treat with this at all?: "Any belief, no matter what its nature, must be dealt with as a fact of some social importance, so long as it is believed by large numbers to be essential to the right ordering of life. (Emphasis mine.) And here's that logic, where Descartes sort of failed: "Civilised man does not discover gods, he discards them." There is so much reason in just this one essay!
That should whet an appetite. I have too many notes. I like "Let us commence with the fact that religion is something that is acquired." - every mind is not born with a theistic belief...that is acquired (and far too often forgotten is that what is acquired is entirely dependent on geography! Where you are born...) Cohen says "In all discussions of theism there is one point that is usually overlooked. This is that theism is in the nature of a hypothesis. And, like every hypothesis, its value is proportionate to the extent to which it offers a satisfactory explanation of the facts with which it professes to deal." And further, theism "exists first as an idea; it only exists as an emotion at a later stage. There is really no such thing as a religious emotion, there are only emotions connected with religion."
Cohen: Not one man in a thousand has the strength. Or conviction. It sure is easier to pass the blame to something unseen and intangible. But it is also intellectually irresponsible.
"Between Atheism and Theism there is no logical halting place." There really isn't. So-called agnosticism is a kludge, and despite what wishers may profess, theistic. ("It has become, in the half century of its existence, as indefinite as 'religion,' and about as enlightening." - About as enlightening!) "As a mental attitude Atheism is quite independent of any theory of cosmic working,..." Mental attitude. I like that. He also presages Stephen Jay Gould's Non-Overlapping Majesteria:
Good book. Thanks to Mr. Harrison, gone seven years tomorrow, for mentioning it in his memoirs. I will come back to this again.… (mais)