Picture of author.

Martin Duberman

Autor(a) de Stonewall

50+ Works 3,505 Membros 27 Críticas

About the Author

Martin Duberman is Distinguished Professor of History Emeritus at City University of New York, where he founded and directed the Center for Lesbian and Gay Studies. He is the recipient of the Bancroft Prize, multiple Lambda Literary Awards, and the Lifetime Achievement Award from the American mostrar mais Historical Association, and he has been a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize and the National Book Award. mostrar menos
Image credit: Joanne Chan

Obras por Martin Duberman

Stonewall (1993) 799 exemplares
Hidden from History: Reclaiming the Gay and Lesbian Past (1989) — Editor — 696 exemplares
Paul Robeson (1988) 335 exemplares
Cures: a Gay Man's Odyssey (1991) 315 exemplares
About Time: Exploring the Gay Past (1991) 165 exemplares
Left Out: A Political Journey (1999) 62 exemplares
Haymarket: A Novel (2005) 61 exemplares
The Worlds of Lincoln Kirstein (2007) 57 exemplares
Howard Zinn: A Life on the Left (2012) 54 exemplares
The Antislavery Vanguard: New Essays on the Abolitionists (1965) — Contribuidor; Editor — 47 exemplares
Has the Gay Movement Failed? (2018) 38 exemplares
Lesbians and Gays and Sports (1994) 34 exemplares
Male Armor (1975) 27 exemplares
Charles Francis Adams, 1807-1886 (1961) 24 exemplares
The uncompleted past (1969) 15 exemplares
Visions of Kerouac: A play (1977) 15 exemplares
Lives of Notable Gay Men and Lesbians: K.D. Lang (1996) — Editor — 14 exemplares
James Russell Lowell (1966) 11 exemplares
Reaching ninety (2023) 7 exemplares
Aylak Kerouac (2017) 2 exemplares
The Memory Bank (1970) 2 exemplares
Toprak Ana - Emma (2017) 1 exemplar
The recorder 1 exemplar
Hold Tight Gently (2016) 1 exemplar
Colonial dudes 1 exemplar
Metaphors 1 exemplar

Associated Works

The Christopher Street reader (1982) — Contribuidor — 118 exemplares
Queer Ideas: The Kessler Lectures in Lesbian & Gay Studies (2003) — Prefácio — 50 exemplares
Lives of Notable Gay Men and Lesbians: James Baldwin (1994) — Editor — 42 exemplares
Lives of Notable Gay Men and Lesbians: Martina Navratilova (1995) — Editor; Editor — 34 exemplares
Paul Robeson: Artist and Citizen (1998) — Contribuidor — 31 exemplares
Lives of Notable Gay Men and Lesbians: Sappho (1994) — Editor — 31 exemplares
Lives of Notable Gay Men and Lesbians: Willa Cather (1994) — Editor — 30 exemplares
Lives of Notable Gay Men and Lesbians: Oscar Wilde (1994) — Editor — 26 exemplares
Best American Plays: 6th Series, 1963-1967 (1971) — Contribuidor — 19 exemplares
Lives of Notable Gay Men and Lesbians: T.E. Lawrence (1995) — Editor — 15 exemplares
Lives of Notable Gay Men and Lesbians: Liberace (1995) — Editor — 10 exemplares

Etiquetado

Conhecimento Comum

Membros

Críticas

i was hyped up to read this, being a queer leftist who agrees with most of the author’s takes on things: i am also disillusioned with mainstream, neoliberal lgbt movements that believe in assimilating into institutions like marriage and the military industrial complex without questioning them, angry about the commercialization of once-radical pride events, and disappointed by the lack of knowledge some queer communities have about lgbtq history. i’m also trans-nonbinary, jewish, autistic, and korean-american. i am someone who is often left out of those mainstream communities, which often privilege a certain expression of (cis, white, male, abled, upper or middle-class) homo- or bisexuality. all in all, i’m pretty much the target audience for this book

i guess it just... didn’t meet my expectations? i thought it was going to be either a) an accessible, not-extremely-academic synopsis of the revolutionaryness of a variety of older lgbt movements internationally compared to the moderation of current ones, b) an assortment of the author’s personal critiques of modern lgbt movements and where he’d like the see them progress, and/or c) concrete suggestions for how we can de-commodify pride, start collectively looking deeper at the systems we’ve fought to integrate into, celebrate our radical roots and maintain a Generally Leftist Vibe™️

this book was none of those things. it was kind of all over the place and really repetitive at points?

the author does not give an overview of past and present queer revolutionary vs reformist movements as I thought it would- which is understandable, as this isn’t a history book. however, he zooms in on a specific historical example (the post-Stonewall Gay Liberation Front), spending the entire first chapter (out of 4) on its politics, in-group dynamics, etc. he seems to view GLF as the beginning of queer revolutionary thought/action, which just isn’t true. obviously it’s an extremely important example- but one in a long list.

the book is also very americancentric- exclusively so, in fact. there is no mention of gay/queer politics anywhere else in the world, or if there are similar dynamics of revolution vs moderation elsewhere. (hint: there are.)

he also talks in the first chapter about Radicalesbians and the “woman identified woman” second wave, with barely any mention of the TERFism that ideology resulted in and that continues to be perpetuated today, particularly in the UK (again a situation where a more international perspective would certainly be helpful). the closest he gets to discussing TERFism and why trans people are turned off by radical second wave lesbian feminism is when he hints at lesbian “objection to transvestism”, which he doesn’t explore further and instead jumps right back to narrating about GLF.

i had to abandon this after finishing the first chapter and going halfway into the next. might continue later, but am pretty disappointed.
… (mais)
 
Assinalado
frailandfreakish | 1 outra crítica | Sep 30, 2023 |
An in-depth treatment of the gay liberation movement from its early beginnings, when it was internally referred to as the homophile movement by many of the mostly conservative gay men behind it, to the transformative moment in 1969 when violence erupted at a mob-run gay bar in the West Village of NYC known as The Stonewall Inn, bringing on a "generational, organizational and ideological shift". The author profiles six individuals through the 1960s and 1970s, whose "stories were different enough to suggest the diversity of gay and lesbian lives, yet interconnected enough to...suggest some of the ...values, perceptions and concerns that centrally characterized the Stonewall generation." This is an important work, obviously painstakingly researched, but I confess I found it slightly weedy reading in parts because of the scrupulous detail included about the multitude of gay rights organizations and publications that came and went, the lack of leadership and the counterproductive in-fighting that made a cohesive national movement so difficult to create for so long. Even after the Stonewall riots seemingly gave moderates and radicals a common goal, consensus as to "message" was as difficult to attain for the LGBTQ "community" as it has proven to be for many other marginalized groups throughout history. The personal stories of the troubled teenager, the African-American jazz club junkie, the buttoned-down wealthy celibate, the Barnard graduate feminist, the transvestite hustler, and the Yippie Vietnam war protestor kept me reading (although I did skim from time to time). Originally published in 1992, my 2019 edition contained a new introduction by the author as well as an epilogue with updates on the lives of his subjects, 4 of whom have died since the book first appeared.… (mais)
 
Assinalado
laytonwoman3rd | 6 outras críticas | Jun 28, 2023 |
Good stuff. Sylvia Rivera's bits especially interesting. Funny how the trans lib movement has reclaimed the Stonewall riots as an action mostly by gender deviants and outlaws to the extent that some actually make Sylvia out to be a trans woman. I'm not sure if her identification changed over time, but at least when she was interviewed for this book she talks about taking a stab at hormones and deciding to go off them because she was more of a genderfuck (my words) than a woman.

Got it from the used book store; definitely worthwhile, although I don't know why it took me so long to finish the last chapter!… (mais)
 
Assinalado
caedocyon | 6 outras críticas | May 8, 2023 |
This is really good! I was expecting something like The Best Little Boy in the World, and they are superficially similar, but I bounced hard off TBLBITW because the author's selfishness and emotional immaturity isn't balanced by anything worthwhile. (eta: and bigotry of literally every kind; I had forgotten what a flaming shitbag the best little boy is.)

In contrast, Duberman's memoir is alternated and interlaced with the broader historical context of gay activism, even where he didn't know or purposely avoided what was going on at the time. I mean: he went to the Stonewall Inn at least once a week in 1969! wasn't there on the night of June 28th! places himself in his apartment a few blocks away! shut away from it all behind his academic work and internalized homophobia and political disdains! Wow.

Duberman's past self is super self-critical and anxious in a way I found almost triggering; looking backwards he doesn't let himself off the hook but balances the hook with compassion. (WOW I am so glad I grew up long after psychoanalysis had fallen out of fashion, because being expected to tear yourself apart that way sounds like my absolute worst and most counterproductive instincts.) He talks a bit about his failure to see or understand lesbian issues and the criticism he sometimes received for it at the time, and he doesn't have much to say about racial or class oppression intersecting with homophobia. Still: do recommend, especially if you're interested in a less-typical view on gay history.
… (mais)
 
Assinalado
caedocyon | May 5, 2023 |

Listas

Prémios

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

B. Ruby Rich Contributor
Randolph Trumbach Contributor
Paula Gunn Allen Contributor
Robert K. Martin Contributor
Lourdes Arguelles Contributor
James D. Steakley Contributor
John Boswell Contributor
Erwin J. Haeberle Contributor
Vivien W. Ng Contributor
John D’Emilio Contributor
Allan Bérubé Contributor
Robert A. Padgug Contributor
Jeffrey Weeks Contributor
Shari Benstock Contributor
Simon Karlinsky Contributor
Madeline David Contributor
Eric Garber Contributor
T. Dunbar Moodie Contributor
Judith C. Brown Contributor
James M. Saslow Contributor
Esther Newton Contributor
David M. Halperin Contributor
Leila J. Rupp Contributor
Howard Zinn Contributor
Silvan S. Tomkins Contributor
Willie Lee Rose Contributor
Robert F. Durden Contributor
James M. McPherson Contributor
Irving H. Bartlett Contributor
John L. Thomas Contributor
Donald G. Mathews Contributor
Staughton Lynd Contributor
Benjamin Quarles Contributor
Robin W. Winks Contributor
Leon F. Litwack Contributor
Fawn Brodie Contributor
David Brion Davis Contributor
Larry Gara Contributor

Estatísticas

Obras
50
Also by
15
Membros
3,505
Popularidade
#7,255
Avaliação
3.9
Críticas
27
ISBN
108
Línguas
3

Tabelas & Gráficos