Mark Haddon

CW: child abuse, incest, sexual assault, sexual content, violence, gore, death, slavery.

The Porpoise is one of those books I was really excited about when I first found out about it: I had loved Mark Haddon's The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, and so I was very much looking forward to this. Then, I somehow forgot about it as it got lost in my massive TBR and I only recently rediscovered it. Unfortunately, it didn't quite meet my expectations.

The Porpoise follows two parallel storylines, with snippets of a third one sprinkled throughout. The first one, set in apparently modern times, follows Angelica, a beautiful young woman who lives in solitude with her rich, overprotective father ever since as a baby she was the sole survivor of a plane crash. But in this gilded cage horrible secrets are kept, until one day a visitor understands more than he should and becomes the target of a skilled assassin. As he flees aboard a ship called The Porpoise, his own story merges with a past tale, a retelling of the myth of Pericles, which forms the second storyline.

The premise was really interesting, but the execution just didn't work for me. I was often confused as the book jumped between the two storylines and the interludes featuring none other than Shakespeare himself. I ended up not caring about any of the characters at all, and there are so many of them (maybe even too many). There was also quite a lot of graphic violence which I was not expecting, and some of the themes were hard to stomach which possibly contributed to my unease when reading this. I alternated between bored and confused for most of this and the few passages and underlying themes that were interesting were sadly just not enough for me to enjoy this book.

I did find the writing to be beautiful (and possibly one of the only redeeming features of this). I really liked the richness of the prose and the vivid descriptions, so I was even sadder when I just couldn't connect with the characters! The underlying critique of wealth and its power to corrupt, persuade or coerce those who are surrounded by it was also interesting but for me it was just too little, too late.

Unfortunately, this one was just not the right fit for me, but given the author's rich writing and wealth of characters and events, I can certainly see how it might work for other readers out there.

I received an e-arc of this book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review. This did not affect my opinion of the book in any way.… (mais)

People think this book has anything to do with autistic people. It doesn't. Please stop using it that way, it sucks.

One thing I remember quite strongly with this is that he (badly) explains the Monty Hall problem and then says that this is proof that "maths is complicated because there aren't single answers" or something vaguely like that when the whole point of that problem is that it has 1 true answer and our own intuition leads us astray. And it was so absurd to read.

Overall I just found it completely unconvincing and the behaviour of everyone involved is inconsistent and horrible.… (mais)