Retrato do autor
1 Work 48 Membros 3 Críticas

Obras por L. Tam Holland

Etiquetado

Conhecimento Comum

There is no Common Knowledge data for this author yet. You can help.

Membros

Críticas

For more reviews, gifs, Cover Snark and more, visit A Reader of Fictions.

Vee Crawford Wong, like many teenagers isn’t happy and doesn’t have a good conception of who he is. The Counterfeit Family Tree of Vee Crawford-Wong is the story of his search for himself, his family’s past, and for a girlfriend. While I wasn’t totally captured by The Counterfeit Family Tree, I did like it and am impressed by Holland’s debut.

Most impressive I think is the first person male narration. Vee definitely feels like a real and flawed teen boy, with his various fantasies and grumpiness with his situation in life. Until I sat down to start writing this review, I actually had no idea the author was a woman, since she did the first initial thing to keep the book from being marketed to girls (it’s sad that this is necessary). I’m always really impressed when authors do first person narration of the opposite gender well, so major props.

Vee is half Chinese and half Texan. He feels weird-looking and like he doesn’t fit in, especially because his family unit is so separated from everything. He doesn’t know any of his grandparents or what his parents’ lives were like before they met. As he goes through the identity crisis that is being a teenager, various school assignments and his own curiosity lead him to want to know about the vast void of his family tree.

The story focuses primarily on Vee’s family. His mother is sweet and his father awkward. He, like many teens, does not appreciate them. He hates them for keeping secrets and a little bit for producing him, this odd-looking mix of a person. Most parents in YA are absent, so I loved how The Counterfeit Family Tree was essentially a journey by which he comes to understand and love his parents. That’s not something you see often in YA.

Running alongside that is the school and romance drama. Vee dreams of the cool girl, Adele, and of being on the basketball team. Instead, he goes to dances with his friend Madison’s super awkward friend, something neither of them is thrilled about and doesn’t make the team. As a sort of consolation prize, he’s made manager of the girls’ basketball team. He learns a lot about what it is he truly wants during the year, by making friends and paying attention to people aside from himself. One of my favorite things was actually the way he and a bully came to a sort of grudging respect for one another.

One thing did irk me about this book, however. Vee made some rather disgusting comments about the basketball team girls before he really knew them:

The girls who played basketball fell into two distinct categories: princess and lesbos. The princesses were thin and smooth and gorgeous, and also bitchy. They were the ones who distracted us. The lesbos made me cower; they had wide shoulders, square jaws, solid thighs, and either flat chests or huge breasts. They didn’t cut one off to shoot arrows, like the real warriors of Lesbos, but they did mush them into tight sports bras and wide-shouldered tank tops and clothes that didn’t fit quite right. They were loud and rude, more like boys, and they squatted on the bleachers and gave one another shoulder rubs before practice.


Of course, I expected that, during his work as the manager, he would come to really respect the girls on the team and see past the narrow-minded stereotypes of this scene. That didn’t really happen though. I thought it was going to with Steffie, but that turned out to be a big fat no. I am not okay with anything in that above paragraph at all. All lesbians are not the same. Holy shit.

Except for that one really frustrating thing, The Counterfeit Family Tree is a good debut novel, one that is a must read for readers looking for YA set in different cultural backgrounds. I would certainly try another book by Holland.
… (mais)
 
Assinalado
A_Reader_of_Fictions | 2 outras críticas | Jan 9, 2015 |
A little choppy--and chapter 23 could have been handled in a less graphic manner--but Vee's search for identity from parents who have cut all ties with their past is still a compelling story. He has a unique voice, and a unique perspective on problem-solving. I do think that the author should have picked EITHER the basketball storytline OR the China storyline, as both could have been better fleshed out. I would have focused more on the visit to China, although I do think Vee's experience there felt genuine, if rather rushed.… (mais)
 
Assinalado
LibraryGirl11 | 2 outras críticas | Jan 17, 2014 |
What started out as a rather mundane novel that I had a hard time getting into, turned into something completely different. I'm not entirely sure when that transition happened, it was after Vee wrote up his fake family history, but before the fake letter was even conceived of. There are a few moments of awkwardness that were almost too much for me (so much second hand embarrassment), but ultimately they were completely worth suffering through because the final few chapters are completely moving and absolutely lovely. Vee's story is not just about growing up in a world of stereotypes, it's about growing up as a person and finding himself (as well as finding out about the world around him). Throughout everything, even when he's lying, Vee is a sympathetic and relatable character.… (mais)
 
Assinalado
callmecayce | 2 outras críticas | Aug 8, 2013 |

Estatísticas

Obras
1
Membros
48
Popularidade
#325,720
Avaliação
½ 3.5
Críticas
3
ISBN
4