Picture of author.

R. W. Southern (1) (1912–2001)

Autor(a) de Western Society and the Church in the Middle Ages

Para outros autores com o nome R. W. Southern, ver a página de desambiguação.

17+ Works 2,754 Membros 18 Críticas 2 Favorited

About the Author

R. W. Southern was a Fellow of Balliol College from 1937 to 1961, Chichele Professor of History at Oxford from 1961 to 1969, and President of St. John's College, Oxford from 1969 to 1981.
Image credit: Royal Historical Society

Séries

Obras por R. W. Southern

Associated Works

Etiquetado

Conhecimento Comum

Membros

Críticas

If Anselm is remembered today, it is usually for one of two of his teachings. One is the so-called ontological argument for the existence of God: God is that object of thought, greater than which cannot be conceived. An object of thought that has real existence is greater than one that does not, therefore . . . . Well, you see where this one is going. The other is his argument for the necessity of the incarnation, which is basically that sin requires an expiation. The collective sin of humanity throughout history is so great that only a sacrifice of infinitely great value could atone for it, therefore . . . . This is known as the satisfaction theory of atonement.
I’ve rendered these arguments in the form in which they are usually cited today, often in a condescending tone of voice, dripping with pity for this old archbishop’s naive medieval mind.
It was then a surprise to read this book, ostensibly a biography, but also a learned discussion of the thought of this philosopher and theologian, and find not only that Anselm's reasoning was more sophisticated than the form in which it is now known, but also that he anticipated many of the objections to his positions, and gave well-reasoned answers to them. With regard to the ontological argument, Southern points out: “It is a simplification to say that [it] aimed at proving the existence of God. What he sought to prove is that justice, goodness, and truth are necessarily united in a single Being, who by definition is God. And since justice, goodness, and truth exist, God cannot not exist” (p. 117)
The book is very much a “life and times”, filling in the background modern readers need to understand both Anselm’s actions and thought. He is repeatedly compared and contrasted with his mentor and predecessor, Lanfranc. His mysticism, his assiduous promotion of education and monastic life are explored, as well as his reflection on the nature of friendship, something he not only thought about, but practiced to an avid degree.
Why should we be interested in a monk who has been dead for 900 years? As Southern points out: “It can scarcely be too strongly emphasized that the span of Anselm’s life covered one of the most momentous periods of change in European history, comparable to the centuries of the Reformation or the Industrial Revolution. It is only against this background that his own balancing of the old and new, his mixture of political conservatism and intellectual and spiritual innovation can be justly measured” (pp. 3–4). The author goes so far as to place Anselm together with Gregory VII and William the Conqueror as the three greatest Europeans of the period. The achievement of this scholarly yet readable study is that this reader came away convinced of the justice of this daring claim.
Usually when I rate a book with five stars, I mean it to indicate that anyone interested in books should read it. That may be going a bit far for a book that might appeal to a limited range of readers, but it is so good that I find it impossible to award fewer than five stars.
… (mais)
 
Assinalado
HenrySt123 | Jul 19, 2021 |
The concept of an ordered human society, both religious and secular, as an expression of a divinely ordered universe was central to medieval thought. In the West the political and religious community were inextricably bound together, and because the Church was so intimately involved with the world, any history of it must take into account the development of medieval society.
Professor Southern's book covers the period from the eighth to the sixteenth century. After sketching the main features of each medieval age, he deals in greater detail with the Papacy, the relations between Rome and her rival Constantinople, the bishops and archbishops, and the various religious orders, providing in all a superb history of the period.… (mais)
1 vote
Assinalado
aitastaes | 5 outras críticas | Dec 5, 2019 |
After this brief appearance he vanished from history, and the whole incident might be dismissed as one of those inexplicable approaches of worlds moving in different orbits and disturbing for a moment the even tenor tenor of their course, were it not for what followed.

My reading progression was routinely distracted last week. This is customary, hardly an aberration. A return to Chinese literature was a possibility. The killings at Charlie Hebdo changed that. I really appreciate Dr. Southern's work. I'm sure there have been successive waves of disputation and engagement since its publication. This remains a brilliant portrait of an age. The 11th and 12th Centuries were brazen efforts at stability. Augustine, Anselm and Boethius appear to be the heroes in this text. I also appreciated Southern's characterization of the opposition between Byzantines and the Latin West: the obscure rituals of the former appearing to the latter like a visit to the Kremlin. There is a subsequent explanation of the Fourth Crusade which appears to be an attempted justification of the sacking of Constantinople. That aside this is a wonderful text.… (mais)
 
Assinalado
jonfaith | 9 outras críticas | Feb 22, 2019 |
In the late fourteenth century religious men had some shattering paradoxes and failures before their eyes. The Benedcitines had retreated from the world, and had become great centres of government and institutions of social cohesion. The Cistercians had gone into the wilderness, and had become the greatest organizers of economic forces before the Fuggers and Medicis. The Franciscans had dedicated their lives to poverty, and were comfortably installed in every large town in Europe. In all this, effective religion(so it seemed) was lost in superficiality.

Dr. Southern's work affected me, it spawned an almost Pauline conversion. No, I haven't embraced the faith, but I felt my thoughts change. A shift was endeavored. Covering a thousand years in a mere 360 pages remains daunting if not impossible. That said, I tended to agree with the learned medievalist when he opines the significance of the church at such a monumental time in European history. What would've been the result if the church had failed? What other institutions could've kept the wolves of the time from the everyman's door?

The book begins with the differences between the Rome and Constantinople and all their doctrinal baggage. He then proceed to traverse the history of the papacy and follows with other offices of the church and concludes with a history of the myriad Orders and their consequent effect on the development of the West. The book is rife with anecdotes and more than a few charts and graphs. It also succeeded in altering the opinion of this crusty agnostic.
… (mais)
 
Assinalado
jonfaith | 5 outras críticas | Feb 22, 2019 |

Listas

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Dorothy Whitelock Contributor
R.W. Hunt Contributor
Mabel H. Mills Contributor
N. B. Lewis Contributor
F. Dvornik Contributor
H. G. Richardson Contributor
Frank Stenton Contributor
Philip Grierson Contributor
William Rees Contributor
J. M. Hussey Contributor
K. B. McFarlane Contributor
Helen Suggett Contributor
Germano Facetti Cover designer
B.H. Looff Translator

Estatísticas

Obras
17
Also by
4
Membros
2,754
Popularidade
#9,312
Avaliação
4.0
Críticas
18
ISBN
44
Línguas
6
Marcado como favorito
2

Tabelas & Gráficos