Clint Van Winkle
Autor(a) de Soft Spots: A Marine's Memoir of Combat and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
About the Author
Obras por Clint Van Winkle
Associated Works
Etiquetado
Conhecimento Comum
- Sexo
- male
Membros
Críticas
Soft Spots: A Marine's Memoir of Combat and Post… por Clint Van Winkle
Esta crítica foi escrita no âmbito dos Primeiros Críticos do LibraryThing.This is a very intense look at one Marine's experience dealing with the rigors of combat and then suffering from post traumatic stress disorder. It makes you realize how much soldiers so through and how we need to be supportive.
I couldn't really get into this book and ended up skimming most of it. It read like something the author had written as prescribed therapy to vanquish his demons. If so, I hope it worked for him and wish him all the best. As a coherent narrative it simply didn't work. It was simply too disjointed and confusing to follow, and the quality of the writing was barely workmanlike. I recognize that this technique of jumping back and forth between past and present and real and imagined was probably meant to reflect the confusion and pain in the writer's mind as he battled - and perhaps continues to battle - PTSD, but the writing simply fails to make it all work.… (mais)
Esta crítica foi escrita no âmbito dos Primeiros Críticos do LibraryThing.This intense memoir provides insight into the life of a Iraq war veteran suffering from PTSD. It is an eye-opening read and one that I would recommend for everyone; especially those who have loved ones who served in Iraq. It provides a more realistic view to war than what we are used to, and while some details are grotesque and horrific to imagine, it is refreshing to get the perspective from someone who has known the reality of war and who is willing to talk about it and how it affected him.
Esta crítica foi escrita no âmbito dos Primeiros Críticos do LibraryThing.Clint Van Winkle has invited us into his life and into his nightmares. He'll be sitting in a bar sharing "normal" life with us but when the news comes on; the ghosts come out - and not just the dead ones.
The writing flows so smoothly between current events, nightmares and memories that it took awhile to get use to it. One minute we're sitting in the living room drinking a beer and the next paragraph we're sitting in Iraq. It happened that fast for him, it happens that fast for us.
This book taught me to be angry. If a minority of our Vets are treated this way, the whole system needs to be taken out and shot.
"Even the Jade Clinic's waiting room seemed inhospitable and cold. The staff's apathy fit right in with the surroundings and they seemed as if they had been specifically handpicked to dole out subpar service. Disheartening isn't a strong enough word to describe what I felt as I watched my fellow veterans being ignored.*"
He mentions some good people in the system but as a whole it leaves a lot to be desired.
This book also taught me appreciation. I've always thought of the military as a group, almost a single body where the feet are very important but still a single body. Now I know it is individuals. The military is made up of people that have the roughest job ever.
Is there a happy ending? Can there ever be a happy ending for a Marine with PTSD? I cried and I laughed and cried some more. Once the story sucked me in it was finished the next day.
Read it. Think about it. Share with your friends. Thank a Vet.
content warning: very realistic war memories
*pg 86 of the Advance Readers' Edition… (mais)
The writing flows so smoothly between current events, nightmares and memories that it took awhile to get use to it. One minute we're sitting in the living room drinking a beer and the next paragraph we're sitting in Iraq. It happened that fast for him, it happens that fast for us.
This book taught me to be angry. If a minority of our Vets are treated this way, the whole system needs to be taken out and shot.
"Even the Jade Clinic's waiting room seemed inhospitable and cold. The staff's apathy fit right in with the surroundings and they seemed as if they had been specifically handpicked to dole out subpar service. Disheartening isn't a strong enough word to describe what I felt as I watched my fellow veterans being ignored.*"
He mentions some good people in the system but as a whole it leaves a lot to be desired.
This book also taught me appreciation. I've always thought of the military as a group, almost a single body where the feet are very important but still a single body. Now I know it is individuals. The military is made up of people that have the roughest job ever.
Is there a happy ending? Can there ever be a happy ending for a Marine with PTSD? I cried and I laughed and cried some more. Once the story sucked me in it was finished the next day.
Read it. Think about it. Share with your friends. Thank a Vet.
content warning: very realistic war memories
*pg 86 of the Advance Readers' Edition… (mais)
You May Also Like
Associated Authors
Estatísticas
- Obras
- 1
- Also by
- 1
- Membros
- 63
- Popularidade
- #268,028
- Avaliação
- 3.8
- Críticas
- 10
- ISBN
- 2
