I have always believed deeply that when you read a book, it should draw some sort of emotion from you, whether it be joy, sadness, disgust, consternation, etc. I can tell you that this book did not disappoint. It left indelible marks upon my very being. I have always known about Carole Lombard and Clark Gable. I have even visited the place where they spent their honeymoon. Please understand this: I am not a star-watcher, nor do I follow their every movement. But it was the situation of these two lives which intrigued me: two people very much in love, and without warning, taken from each other.

Admittedly, it is something that happens to people every day. But you do not read about it every day. You do not read about their lives quite the way Mr. Matzen has written. He has interspersed every other chapter with Ms. Lombard and Mr. Gable's life from their beginning right up until the end together. You learn things that are not the fodder of fan magazines - the tragedies that befell her when she was young, and the reason she lived her life at such a fast pace. She felt she had to; that she needed to, as if each day meant something important, and she was not going to let one minute slip by unnoticed.

Mr. Gable lived his life quite differently from hers, and reading it, you wouldn't expect the two completely disparate personalities to come together at all. But they did - and they lived furiously; and when the news of her death becomes a reality to him, it shakes him up and shapes him as nothing else has ever done before.

As I said, every other chapter is about these two, but it is what is in between that is the most heart-wrenching of all. He allows us into the lives of the others on the plane, the people who were there and some that were not supposed to be (although I suppose, in a way they were supposed to be); a glimpse of their lives and the ones they left behind who were waiting for word even while Mr. Gable was hurrying to find his wife, hoping against hope that everyone was wrong.

At the last, there is the story of the people who gave their time and effort climbing up that mountain on a cold January day, trying to see if there was anyone alive who needed rescuing, and their stories are here as well, and just as thought-provoking. A sad read, but an intense one, and worth the time. Highly recommended. ( )

Good read if you love old Hollywood. Such a shame that she died at such a young age. One small change and she would have lived. I also liked how the author focused on the other people who lost their lives in the plane crash. ( )

Detailed stories of an American tragedy

As a huge Gable and Lombard fan, I was familiar with the death of Carole Lombard in the tragic plane crash outside of Las Vegas. However, this book shares so much more information! Stories of the many other passengers on that ill-fated flight, details of the flight crew, and even the condition of the plane (overweight/overloaded) are described in great detail. The author personally visited the still-authentic crash site while writing this book. It contains both the technical and emotional aspects of the tragic accident and the tolls on the families, airline, and even the country in its aftermath.

Definitely a must read for anyone with any interest in the subject matter. ( )

I began to read this with some trepidation… I didn't want these two to lose their luster. I also didn't want to cry over them, but I was resigned to that – when one of a loving couple is going to crash into a mountain in the course of a book, tears are going to happen.

In the end, was the Great Love Affair between Gable and Lombard everything fond fans say it was? I don't know. Probably not. (Two words: Lana Turner.) Would they have been divorced in a few years? Maybe. But it doesn't really matter. It's sort of like JFK's presidency – cut untimely short, there's so much room left for fantasy and imagining.

And, also like JFK's presidency, press coverage resulted in a public perception of the situation which didn't bear much resemblance to reality. Which goes back to the beginning of this review. I kind of like the fantasy, the he-for-her-only-and-she-for-him illusion. It's not any fun to become resigned to the fact that Gable was a dog, and Lombard was no saint herself. But … well, the couple in this book are human beings, not Movie Stars. There's the difference.

This is the story of a woman described as the kind of friend everyone longs for, energetic and loyal and fierce – a fireball – and the fireball that ended her. I knew little enough about her, except for her earlier marriage to William Powell, her love of animals, and the romance with Gable; I had no idea about the other accident that changed the course of Carole Lombard's life. Shocked, I felt stunningly unobservant never to have noticed the scars … until I went looking for them. They're most definitely there in some pictures – I can't say I'm not unobservant – but in my defense, makeup and lighting were used skillfully to hide or at least minimize them. Her tremendous heart, her "salty" language – and the reason for the language; her "Causes" which ranged from parrots to people and everywhere in between… No, this exploration of her life and death did not dim Carole Lombard in my eyes.

Supplemental to the tale of Gable and Lombard and that damned mountain, this was a look inside Hollywood of the 20's and 30's, and how Gable hated playing Rhett Butler but Lombard longed to play Scarlett, and the often vicious process of casting and celebrity. "The result is equal parts biography, rescue effort, and mystery; it’s also a love story and an unimaginable tragedy that continues to haunt me, as it may haunt you." And it's about early air travel, the uncertain first steps of the country into war, about the other people who were on that damned plane and the people they left behind. It could have been a scattered mess – but it's not. The method in which Matzen tells the history, in which the timeline is cut in half and braided until about the 60% point where they catch up to each other, and the story of Gable and Lombard is woven together with that of all the other people involved in the fireball, works to deepen the story. I don't think it's easy to tell a story with a foregone conclusion; reading another biography of a beloved celebrity, I thought about how I would probably get his death out of the way early and soften the blow a bit. I mean, as with this book, I went into it knowing full well that he died some years ago, but the exploration of the long illness that killed him, culminating in his death and funeral and a brief aftermath, left me a bit wrecked at the end – testament more to how I felt about the actor than to the book. So I liked the fact that there is no coyness or artificial buildup to the very definitely foregone conclusion in Fireball. The emotional impact is still powerful, the description of the crash is horrific in its detail, but it's not what the reader closes the book with for the last time.

The cause, or rather possible cause of the crash is explored, and no real answer attained. I found it remarkable that even in this story there are conspiracy theories.

Yeah, I cried. "If I can do it, so can you." I learned a bit more about the Golden Age Hollywood stars I love so much – Spencer Tracy, and Lucille Ball, and William Powell. Gable and Lombard. And it didn't hurt my affection for them – on the contrary. They are more fully formed in my mind's eye, and knowing that I like them as human beings will enhance my enjoyment of their performances.

We're not really supposed to quote from advance copies of books, but … well, that never really stopped me before, and I want to make note of: "…Stand your ground, and make it look like you were planting flowers on that ground all the while." I'd like that cross-stitched and framed.

And I want to close with another quote, the author's summation of why I wish I'd known the woman born as Jane Alice Peters: "the soft-hearted, hard-charging, caffeine-fueled, self-promoting, profanity-laced, nicotine-addicted, business-oriented, and usually optimistic sexpot and perpetual motion machine known to the world as Carole Lombard". God bless – and angels keep. ( )

So many people are fascinated by Hollywood stars, and I admit I am as well, but mostly by stars of yesteryear. I was a little wary of such a detailed book about a plane crash and feared it might be dry. No worries on that account. The author did a good job of juxtaposing biographical information of Lombard & Gable along with the accounts of the air disaster. Descriptions of the terrain at Mt. Potosi painted a vivid picture of just how horrific was the crash and what an ordeal was faced by the would-be rescuers/FBI/CAB/investigators. The author also remembered and paid tribute to the flight crew and soldiers who lost their lives as well. Yes, Carole Lombard was the most famous, but all those other people lost their lives, were somebody's children or spouse or parent and were just as important. A very well done book. ( )