The Doomspell series was a collection of books I was hoping to dive into to and really enjoy as it sounded like such a promising change to the current books on the market at the moment.

Its opening chapter was incredibly gripping, and at first made for a promising story about an evil witch dominating a world and kidnapping children in hope of finding extra strength.

However, I found myself thinking it was just a remake of the snow queen, which I don't overly like anyway. As the story progresses it loses my interest. I put the book down and left it for ages without a second thought hence why it took me so long to read.
The characters were likable but if any of them died in the story I would just shrug it off as an 'Oh well sh** happens' moment.

Overall this book let me down, its opening was the most gripping point and I think i'll politely pass on the second.
( )

This review covers the entire trilogy:

I like to read children’s books, especially ones that are fantasy based. As a friend of mine put it once, “I have a thing for Portal fantasy”. And this is exactly that!

With a dash of other-world-fantasy too.

The Doomspell Trilogy has very clear influences coming from Tolkien and C S Lewis, with elements such as witches who love winter, animals that can talk, and children’s innocence being very prominent in the stories. The trilogy follows Rachel and Eric, siblings who are among the first of a new race of humans who can control magic. The main villains of the series are witches – beings coming from another planet who can control magic, beings who can change their shape and fly and control the elements and certain animals. Each book in the trilogy takes on a different witch, or race of witches, at a time. From a singular witch, to an entire planet of them, to the witches’ ex-slaves who have now risen up, Rachel and Eric are subject to battle after battle against forces that two pre-teens really shouldn’t be able to battle. But they do.

What I really want to discuss about this series, however, isn’t the plot or the characters, but its themes, which are very prevalent once you look a little deeper into the novels.

Theme One: Innocence

In this universe, adults cannot use magic, but anybody under a certain age (let’s assume 16, for the sake of argument) can. By the third book, magic is a widespread phenomenon across the world, with every single child and young teenager being able to use magic. Adults are left behind, sometimes terrorized in certain parts of the world. Children have free reign, flying everywhere, stealing whatever they want, and doing whatever they please. The world has changed and the kids are in control. But once they start to become adults, it’s over for them, and they lose their magic. Why? What could possibly lead to this?

If you read the header above, then you definitely can see that I think it’s because of innocence. Now whether this be innocence in the term of sex, or maybe cynicism, or maybe even just people starting to become more aware of the world around them. The fact is that children start to lose their powers once they become ‘young adults’, and suddenly they’re no longer allowed into this world that they used to inhabit and enjoy. I think that McNish here is trying to show how magical innocence is, with the magic that they use being pure and wonderful. While there are magical users who are evil (see: witches), their magic is significantly rougher and more dangerous; it is a different brand of magic. The wizards, who control magic that is much stronger and brighter than the children do, can be seen as adults who have retained their innocence and faith in the world, and never became jaded; they are the best magic users because they never let themselves become hardened by the world.

Theme Two: Diversity and Tolerance

There are a group of children within the series who cannot use magic. They have abnormally large ears, do not speak much, and have to be carried around by a faithful magic user at all times if they want to go anywhere. These children can be seen as a reference, name and all, to children on the autism spectrum, who are seen as not being as 100% capable as their peers (although this is definitely not a hard truth). There is also an element of preaching tolerance in the trilogy.

All in all, I would definitely recommend this book to anybody who wants to read something not-so-well-known and good. It does have it’s brilliant moments, and it also does fit in with what people who look for fantasy like. It’s a light, summer read that you can swallow in a week, and it’s also one of the only books I know of where magic is treated in a different way than in other literary universes, which can be a breath of fresh air!

Final rating: 3/5. It is for children after all, so the writing style isn’t the best. But it is a good read for the summer! ( )

[This is a review I wrote in 2007]

Magic, mystery, suspense, action-packed gripping fantasy plot, well-written, lots of vivid imagery... it's a short novel and I literally couldn't stop until I'd finished it! Can't wait to read the next one in the trilogy.

It's easy to empathise with the main characters, brother and sister, Rachel and Eric. Snatched away from their homes on Earth and thrown into a world of dark magic we follow their fight to overthrow evil.

For all ages 8+, and it would make a great film! ( )

At first there was something I didn’t like about this book. As I went on, drawn into the story, I read it in about 24 hours, I realized it’s simply that I am not used to reading or hearing for that matter children from England. That was it. It wasn’t that I didn’t like it, it was just weird for me, and I love that about this book. With that said, I thoroughly enjoyed the story. I see the comparisons to C.S. Lewis and I think they are well deserved. I look forward to digging into the next book! ( )

Dieses Buch würde ich jedem Kind im Alter von 8 Jahren in die Hand drücken!

Die Struktur ist von meiner pädagogischen Seite her, sehr einfach gehalten. Die Geschichte Kindgerecht und Charaktere leicht zu verstehen. Es ist zudem auch noch sehr bildhaft beschrieben und regt die Fantasie des Kindes an. Und da ich sowieso der Meinung bin, dass Kinder schon sehr Früh mit Büchern in Berührung kommen sollten, ist es daher geradezu perfeckt. Vielleicht eher etwas für Mädchen aber dass kommt eigentlich immer auf das Kind individuell an.

Dennoch gebe ich dem Buch nur 2 Sterne, da ich es Streckenweise zu einfach gehalten fand und die Geschichte eigentlich noch viel mehr Potenzial hat, als der Autor an arbeit letztendlich hineingesteckt hatte. ( )