Shubnum Khan
Autor(a) de The Djinn Waits a Hundred Years
Obras por Shubnum Khan
Etiquetado
Conhecimento Comum
- Sexo
- female
- Nacionalidade
- South Africa
- Locais de residência
- Durban, South Africa
- Educação
- University of KwaZulu-Natal
Membros
Críticas
The Djinn Waits a Hundred Years por Shubnum Khan
https://tamaranth.blogspot.com/2024/04/2024053-djinn-waits-hundred-years.html
A vivid and beautiful gothic tale that surprised me. Took a little bit to get into it at first but I soon saw this story play out in my mind like I was watching it on a screen. The characters from both timelines are so full. Loved this immensely.
And you will not be disappointed if you read this in audio. Soneela Nankani is phenomenal. Immediately added a bunch of her narrated books to my TBR.
And you will not be disappointed if you read this in audio. Soneela Nankani is phenomenal. Immediately added a bunch of her narrated books to my TBR.
Recommended: if you know what you're getting
For a slow paced atmospheric read, for the life story of every character involved, for unexpected dual timelines, not for much magic or djinn-ness.
Thoughts:
Oh, dear. Well. This was a disappointment for me. Sigh.
This is reminding me of Remarkably Bright Creatures which promised and was hyped on the idea of getting a perspective of narration from an octopus, and then had like 6 pages of octopus narration total. It wasn't delivering what I expected, and this book was similar. I love magic and djinn, and that was a big part of why I was curious about this one. The title is named for the djinn, so I thought it would be more present, but it doesn't show up until about halfway through and is limited in it's importance except for a few moments. The djinn was more of a narrative bridge between the past and present, and a way to give a concrete narrator to events that would otherwise only be seen through some unspecified omniscience.
And about that bridge between past and present. I wasn't expecting to be suddenly thrown into the past with new characters, and I didn't really appreciate it. A large part of this is because I was already struggling to care about the current-day story and characters, so to then get a whole new set to learn was discouraging. I ended up liking some of the characters in the past timeline more, at least, but that meant coming back to present day was that much harder.
It excelled in making the house a character, and building a robust sense of atmosphere. There's some light personification in a sort of folklore-mystical way, where it didn't feel like magic. Instead it felt like it was exposing what actually happens, in every building, always, even today, and that was an interesting thought that led to questioning what the buildings I know are feeling. Typing that out feels a bit goofy, but oh well!
Overall though... I was a bit bored. It was a very observational experience rather than an active one, and with one bright exception, there wasn't much that happened. It was more about simple interactions, learning about people, and understanding the past events. It was okay, but it wasn't my favorite. I read it, but I read it slowly and with a little reluctance each time I went back. If you enjoy something more akin to a character study with a very slight touch of magical realism and some historical dual timelines, this can work. If you're looking for something with an active story or more obvious magic elements, take it as a miss.
Thank you to NetGalley and Viking for a free advanced copy. This is my honest review.… (mais)
For a slow paced atmospheric read, for the life story of every character involved, for unexpected dual timelines, not for much magic or djinn-ness.
Thoughts:
Oh, dear. Well. This was a disappointment for me. Sigh.
This is reminding me of Remarkably Bright Creatures which promised and was hyped on the idea of getting a perspective of narration from an octopus, and then had like 6 pages of octopus narration total. It wasn't delivering what I expected, and this book was similar. I love magic and djinn, and that was a big part of why I was curious about this one. The title is named for the djinn, so I thought it would be more present, but it doesn't show up until about halfway through and is limited in it's importance except for a few moments. The djinn was more of a narrative bridge between the past and present, and a way to give a concrete narrator to events that would otherwise only be seen through some unspecified omniscience.
And about that bridge between past and present. I wasn't expecting to be suddenly thrown into the past with new characters, and I didn't really appreciate it. A large part of this is because I was already struggling to care about the current-day story and characters, so to then get a whole new set to learn was discouraging. I ended up liking some of the characters in the past timeline more, at least, but that meant coming back to present day was that much harder.
It excelled in making the house a character, and building a robust sense of atmosphere. There's some light personification in a sort of folklore-mystical way, where it didn't feel like magic. Instead it felt like it was exposing what actually happens, in every building, always, even today, and that was an interesting thought that led to questioning what the buildings I know are feeling. Typing that out feels a bit goofy, but oh well!
Overall though... I was a bit bored. It was a very observational experience rather than an active one, and with one bright exception, there wasn't much that happened. It was more about simple interactions, learning about people, and understanding the past events. It was okay, but it wasn't my favorite. I read it, but I read it slowly and with a little reluctance each time I went back. If you enjoy something more akin to a character study with a very slight touch of magical realism and some historical dual timelines, this can work. If you're looking for something with an active story or more obvious magic elements, take it as a miss.
Thank you to NetGalley and Viking for a free advanced copy. This is my honest review.… (mais)
This is one of those books that haunts you long after you've finished it, much like the djinn lingered in Akbar Manzil. Khan does an amazing job of bringing the past and present inhabitants of the mansion to life, drawing the reader into a mysterious and tragic tale. I will warn you - it can get a bit dark at times, and it will play your heart strings like a concert pianist. I got wrapped up in the book pretty quickly, and it moves along smoothly at a good paced. Highly recommend!
Prémios
Estatísticas
- Obras
- 2
- Membros
- 120
- Popularidade
- #165,356
- Avaliação
- 3.9
- Críticas
- 8
- ISBN
- 7